why did schindler save stern from the train?

To survivor Murray Pantirer, a Schindler Jew, he elaborated, I was a Nazi, and I believed that the Germans were doing wrong when they started killing innocent people, it didnt mean anything to me that they were Jewish, to me they were just human beings, menschen. What excuse does Schindler give the officers to save the children's lives? Its yours. The candle is lit to show these people survived, He is a member of the Nazi party, war profiteer, and munitions maker and profits off of slave labor. They are taken and the goods are confiscated by the Nazis. Ironically, after he orders her to be killed, what direction does he then give? Femia, Lisa. Qu____________es Mara! Emilie, Oskar's wife, says that ___________ makes all the difference between success and failure. What was his plan? I want these. Schindler is in bed with his mistress. I knew the people who worked for me. he specially needed Jews investors because Jews, by law, cannot own businesses. The question of what motivated Oskar Schindler to help save the lives of more than 1,000 Jews lingers after watching Schindler's List, which was rereleased last week for its 25th anniversary. "Schindlers List Quotes and Analysis". 2. MeduelenmucholosojosDebesdejardefumar\begin{array}{ll} The patients are given painkillers because the Nazi shoot them. Schindler's List People and Quotes and Short, Sociology Readings (Match reading with author), Vocabulary for Achievement: Fourth Course, Harold Levine, Norman Levine, Robert T. Levine. What makes Oskar Schindler such a good example? What does Schindler want the Jewish workers in his factory to make? Not affiliated with Harvard College. clear. In a later meeting, Stern informed Schindler that he could use Jewish slave labour to staff his factory, Deutsche Emaillewarenfabrik (German Enamelware Factory) at a lower price than Polish laborers, which would also allow those laborers to be protected from deportations. what are some examples you observed while watching, Why did Schindler save stern from the train. He doesn't want anyone to know it's a Jew he's enjoying. But Sterns attitude softens as Schindler becomes an active Schindler, known first and foremost until this time as a pragmatic businessman, risked his life to save the Jewish workers in his employment, and eventually caused his own bankruptcy in setting up . He views the Jewish people as humans, not commodities. How does he use these things to his advantage? They hate you there. For much of the film, it seems not as if Schindler wants to actively protect the Jews. In this quote, Schindler tries to influence Goeth to cease his random slaughter. What does Schindler want the Jewish workers in his factory to make? Thank yourselves. Hath not a Jew eyes? I feel for you, Helen. He walks with Schindler and apologizes for forgetting his work card at home. What disturbing item is dumped in front of him to evaluate? Today will be remembered. Schindler's List essays are academic essays for citation. in the film. Why? A Jewish worker is shown evaluating gold watches, etc. The Holocaust started on January 1933 and ended on May 8, 1945. His monologue to Helen is his attempt to reconcile being attracted to a Jew. Russian officer: You have been liberated by the Soviet army! Schindler tells Stern that he will pay the investors in product, not money, because money was worthless in the ghettos. Oskar Schindler, they'll say. Where does the little girl in the red coat find a place to hide? GradeSaver, 15 October 2012 Web. Food seems to be the key to survival, but in reality it killed more people than it saved. Goeth says this to Helen while she stands silent, terrified, and helpless. He was exercising his power not to kill (but he can't and kills him). Goeth orders the officer to shoot her, despite protests of her necessity. While offering welcome and food, Schindler comes across as the benevolent savior that he is now remembered as. He somehow had the knowledge to recognize me and he called me by the name of Rumak. Schindler thinks he will be remember, and indeed he his, but it is not for what he predicts. Goeth recites the frustration and resentment the Nazi party has for the Jews who came to Poland with nothing and excelled. How does he use these things to his advantage? Emilie, Oskar's wife, says that __________ makes all the difference between success and failure. Hoss believes it is a fair deal to offer three hundred different Jews, because one Jew is the same as the next. Who gets the salary earned by the Jewish workers? The scene with the piles of Jewish belongings in a German warehouse serves to once again show the vast extent of the Holocaust. Jewish workers would be cheaper than Poles. Why did the two men behave so differently? One of the most courageous was Oskar Schindler. Modelo Tu hijo es un estudiante muy bueno. The following day, Goeth tries to follow Schindler's advice, but finds himself unable to do so. He tells Schindler that the list is always correct, and Stern must not be an essential worker. Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. Power is when you have justification to kill, but you choose not to. Comprehending the Holocaust One Name at a Time. On multiple occasions after the war, Schindler confronted the question of why he helped Jews survive the Holocaust. The Holocaust is an important because it shapes who he is. David demande o est Sandrine. The scene changes and now the camera is in the backseat of a car with two German officials. The train comes, we turn it around. He was convinced he was dealing with real people, and that was the most important thing. He also felt close to him. You'll also receive an email with the link. He takes him out of the line, saying he is a skilled worker and gets him a worker's card. Who is the woman who arrives unannounced at Schindler's apartment door? It also hints at mass extermination, without actually showing the violence. These monstrous events are the result of not acting because they felt no personal connection. He beats her frequently and she is often scared for her life. I decided I am going to work against them and I am going to save as many as I can.. Escoge la mejor respuesta para cada situacin. It creates a lot of paperwork. Stern was scared because he shouldnt shake the hand of a German. Like any other jew he was trapped in a ghetto, transported to a camp, and evaluated in the selection. But when most people think rich people are greedy his transformation proves otherwise. A ring that has Hebrew writing that says whoever saves one life, save the world entire. You may cancel your subscription on your Subscription and Billing page or contact Customer Support at [email protected]. Today is history and you are part of it. This quote is also representative of the sexual subjugation that women throughout history, including during World War II, have had to endure. Ill cut you three hundred units from it. He yelled out Rumak. Spielberg wishes to convey this phrase as the message of the film. The 1,000 came from the two lists Goldberg made, and Crowe believes the other 98 were people who came. Stories vary as to how this came to be. reflects Schindlers change throughout the film. Ben Kingsley plays him as a proud man with a mission and Schindler provides an opposing, moral viewpoint. Stern sets the wheels in motion, making the factory a haven for the Krakw Jews before Schindler even notices what is occurring. A bag full of teeth and gold cavity covers on them. Furthermore, this quote establishes a connection between Schindler and the Jewish people. The best known of these factories today is the "Emalia" factory in Krakw. The young man with the list makes the conductor stop the train, and Stern is removed safely. Why are they playing music for the children? Stern was born 25 January 1901, in Krakw. who is the woman who arrives unannounced at Schindler's apartment door? Name three things that happen to the women. The name Rumak stuck and evidently Schindler remembered that name so he still remembered Rumak. This conversation occurs between Goeth and Schindler after a party at Goeth's villa. Music from a children's choir plays as the camera gives an aerial shot of the action. Stern's brother Natan was also one of the Schindlerjuden in the procession. Dealing on the black market, he lived in high style. Schindler needed Stern to run his opperation. He is smart and knows how to get his way. The girl hides in a hollowed floor, and the mom hides under the stairs until they are reunited. He was put into labor camps at a young age and was torn from his family. [3], After the liberation of the Brnnlitz camp by the Red Army, Stern moved to Paris and eventually emigrated to Israel. by using his connections and monetary resources, Stern plays just A little girl in a red coat is noticeable because her coat is the only color in the shot. Qu estudiante es tu hijo! Schindler thus insists upon receiving the women from his original list at Zwittau-Brinnlitz. What are the key things that he says or does that depict him in a negative light? He expresses his admiration for her and his internal disbelief that she can truly be a vermin. The Question and Answer section for Schindlers List is a great What is his response? Emilie says if she is to stay, it must be on one condition. He persuades Goeth to sell him his workers, as well as Goeth's maid, Helen Hirsch, to work in his factory in Czechoslovakia. Schindler: That's what the Emperor said. Elie Wiesel was one of the most remembered Jew from the holocaust. He buys his workers from the concentration camps so he can take those people with him. Schindler: Yes. What is Schindler's present and what is inscribed on it? There is only room for one, so Chaja leaves Danka there. It was just as the situation had begun to grow worse for the Jews, when the Sword of Damocles was already over our heads, that I had this meeting with Oskar Schindler. What would have happened to him if he had not? The camera cuts to Stern, standing alone among the crowd, staring in horror at the activities around him. He takes him out of the line, saying he is a skilled worker and gets him a worker's card. What is Schindler's reaction as he watches the liquidation of the ghetto? Schindlers treatment of Jews during the last years of the war contrasts starkly with Amon Goeths, the notorious SS commandant of Plaszow where many Jewish laborers who worked for Schindler were imprisoned. Why are the candles in color? From this moment on, Jews will no longer live in the safety of the ghetto, but in concentration camps. She has died, Schindler is shocked and sad. Early on, he expresses And I heard from Itzhak Stern that one day in 39, maybe October, maybe November, a German came in and wanted er, said good morning and wanted to shake his hand. Stern, like Schindler, is an opportunist, and he is the At the end of the film, Stern's widow Sophia appears in a procession of Schindlerjuden and the actors who portrayed them, placing stones on Schindler's grave on Mount Zion, which is a Jewish tradition showing respect for the deceased. Read the statement below and complete the exclamation with the appropriate nouns. This quote illustrates the Nazi belief that Jews were not truly human. They had Aryanized the factories, of course. Thanks for creating a SparkNotes account! Why do you think Goeth didn't kill the boy who couldn't get the bathtub stains off? Rudolph Hoss is the commander at Auschwitz, the concentration camp to which the train of women is accidentally sent. Scene 11 opens in a dark room. Schindler: Three hundred and fifty workers on the factory floor with one purpose: to make money - for me! In regards to Schindler and his Jews, however, neither party deserves to be hunted. What happens to the little girl in the red coat? In the fireplace. Schindler followed his suggestion, which began his rescue activities of Jews during the Holocaust. What does Schindler suggest they do for the people in the cattle cars? Elie Wiesel was a teenager that grew up in Sighet, Transylvania, who was taken from his home, along with his family, to a concentration camp in Auschwitz and then later moved to Buchenwald in 1944. And Stern told him, Excuse me sir, I am a Jew. Well Schindler said It doesnt matter to me who you are, you are a man and he shook his hand. Schindler: Power is when we have every justification to kill, and we don't. Why, according to the commandment of the Labor camp (Amon Goeth), is "today history" ? With nothing they came and with nothing they flourished. It tells the compelling true story of . All around its margins lies the gulf. Jews would be interested in investing because they are technically not allowed to own businesses, so this would be their chance to. 4 minutes. Pfefferberg's attempt to escape through the sewers is unsuccessful and he only escapes the soldiers narrowly. Sterns motivationto help his peopleis abundantly And the salary goes to the SS anyways. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. Until this point, Stern is concerned that money will ultimately win out over human life. This highlights the difference between the two men, despite the fact that they are both men of power. These unsuccessful attempts at escape highlight the helplessness of the Jewish position. Described by some as an opportunist, he took advantage of the Nazi German policy of "Aryanizing . The two young men enter the shot behind him and also begin calling for Stern. Why does Schindler go to see Itzhak Stern, the Jewish accountant? He dresses up in suit, knows how to bribe people, and sorts through money. And if a German asked you a question in the street it was compulsory for you to precede your answer with 'I am a Jew.' But it was only on December 1st that we had to begin wearing the Star of David. What happens to Jews who resist the liquidation? Oskar Schindler had many great traits that include, courageous, integrity, Schindler to the Rescue All attempts are unsuccessful. He has to live with these things for his entire life, he has to life with watching the annihilation. In Paszw, Stern and his brother Natan, along with Mietek Pemper and Joseph Bau, were forced to work in Paszw's office, where they came into frequent contact with the camp's notorious commandant, Amon Gth. They took hold. Why does Schindler tell Helen that he is certain Goeth won't shoot her? When the commandment is unsatisfied with the number of hinges a worker has produced, what happens? Schindler needed Stern to run his opperation. Joyce, Meghan ed. Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. He says Goeth won't shoot her because he enjoys her too much, According to Schindler, one truly has power when he does what. 20% The camera provides a close up of his mistresss oblivious look before panning to an expression of horror on Schindler's face. SCHINDLER'S LIST is one of the most powerful movies of all time. Goeth says this to his soldiers before the liquidation of the ghetto. Six hundred years ago, when elsewhere they were footing the blame for the Black Death, Casimir the Great - so called - told the Jews they could come to Krakow. We also saw him placing orders for luxury items such as chocolate and cigars. When the commandant is unsatisfied with the number of hinges a worker has produced, what happens? The man is almost shot, but the guns wouldn't work, so he lived. Why does Schindler suggest they do for the people in the cattle cars? Pfefferberg scopes out the sewers for Mila, risking his own life in the hope that he could save both of them. How does Stern rescue the university professor? He finalized a list of 1200 Jews he was able to save with his set up. They believe him and leave him alone. [] I somehow left an impression on him because when I met after the war, he greeted me warmly as if he knew me forever. During the Holocaust, Elie Wiesel changes from a spiritual, sensitive little boy to a spiritually dead unemotional man. ", he follows it with "Where would I be?" Hoss: I have a shipment coming in tomorrow. Schindler realizes that his workers, Stern included, face certain death at the hands of the Nazis, so he decides to spend his fortune to save as many Jews as he can. The director 's decision to begin in full color with candles which fade into black and white not only helps the viewer enter a solemn and serious mindset, but it also minimizes distractions as to focus solely on the film 's message while the story unfolds. $24.99 Life [ edit] Early life [ edit] Stern was born 25 January 1901, in Krakw. You nearly talked me into it, didnt you? If you don't see it, please check your spam folder. What does Goeth say about the history of Krakow? It was reported that Schindler "cried inconsolably" at his funeral. is the one who discovers a way to channel his essentially forced The Reasons Why Oskar Schindler Save The Jews, Why did Oskar Schindler Save the Jews? as large a role by driving Schindler gently from behind the scenes. The following day, Goeth tries to follow Schindler's advice, but finds himself unable to do so. By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from SparkNotes and verify that you are over the age of 13. Purchasing While she is attempting to escape, she runs into a young boy who is working as a Jewish policeman. The shot continues to go back and forth between the two men as a voice-over by Goeth is heard. During the time Hitler was beginning to rise to power, a huge population of Germany was supporting the newly coming leader Adolf Hitler. A hoard of soldiers runs into the ghetto and storms the apartments, throwing personal items from the balconies. The young man with the list makes the conductor stop the train, and Stern is removed safely. He beats Helen not out of frustration with her, but with himself. This statement not only dehumanizes the Jewish people, but also is the first in a series of statements in the film about paperwork. Whoever saves one life saves the world entire. Who is it that captures his attention during the liquidation? Goeth outlines this view to both his soldiers and the viewers before the first major bloody scene of the film. What is stern typing? There is then a close up of Goeth's profile as he gazes onto a building project where a young woman is yelling orders at workers. This causes the viewer to believe that he is uncaring and not compassionate, even to those close with him. Tomorrow you'll begin the process of looking for survivors of your families. Continue to start your free trial. These are the final lines of a monologue that Geoth speaks to Helen, his maid. Schindler says this to his male workers as they arrive in Moravia from Plaszow. Such as Oskar Schindler who may have just been one person but made a huge difference by saving a thousand people. Oskar Schindler's perspective of the Holocaust was that of many people, wrong. Understanding Goeth's need for power, he attempts to persuade him by telling him that power and violence are not the same. [2], Krakw's Jews were imprisoned in the Krakw Ghetto six months after German troops invaded Krakw. I know you've had a long journey, but it's only a short walk further to the factory where hot soup and bread is waiting for you. Why would Jews be interested in investing in Schindler's project? He has gone through every painful event in the holocaust and the most painful event was knowing how his father died and that his father death brought him joy not sorrow. What is Schindler's present and what is inscribed on it? At the labor camp, what is Helen selected by the commandant to do? The rest were sent to various death camps across Poland. [9].mw-parser-output .reflist{font-size:90%;margin-bottom:0.5em;list-style-type:decimal}.mw-parser-output .reflist .references{font-size:100%;margin-bottom:0;list-style-type:inherit}.mw-parser-output .reflist-columns-2{column-width:30em}.mw-parser-output .reflist-columns-3{column-width:25em}.mw-parser-output .reflist-columns{margin-top:0.3em}.mw-parser-output .reflist-columns ol{margin-top:0}.mw-parser-output .reflist-columns li{page-break-inside:avoid;break-inside:avoid-column}.mw-parser-output .reflist-upper-alpha{list-style-type:upper-alpha}.mw-parser-output .reflist-upper-roman{list-style-type:upper-roman}.mw-parser-output .reflist-lower-alpha{list-style-type:lower-alpha}.mw-parser-output .reflist-lower-greek{list-style-type:lower-greek}.mw-parser-output .reflist-lower-roman{list-style-type:lower-roman}, This article is about the accountant. What ceremony is happening at night in the labor camp? The camera lingers on one worker's aghast face after a pile of gold-capped teeth are presented to him. 8. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum inspires people worldwide to confront hatred, prevent genocide, and promote human dignity. When Schindler hears that Stern has been placed on a deportation train, he is very concerned. When Spielberg cuts back and forth between Goeth and Schindler shaving, he highlights the similarity between the two men: greed. Cuts to Stern, the concentration camps to believe that he says or does that depict him a... Would I be? shipment coming in tomorrow storms the apartments, throwing personal items from the camps! One of the film, excuse me sir, I am a Jew,! He could save both of them young man with the list makes the conductor the! Stern has been placed on a deportation train, he lived in high style hears that Stern has placed. Pile of gold-capped teeth are presented to him if he had not you... Nazi belief that Jews were imprisoned in the Krakw ghetto six months after German troops Krakw! Their chance to born 25 January 1901, in Krakw lingers on one worker 's card under the until. Prevent genocide, and Stern must not be an essential worker allowed to own businesses, so can! To be hunted people, wrong storms the apartments, throwing personal items from the Holocaust helplessness of the.! A man and he shook his hand thinks he will pay the investors product... Your spam folder is always correct, and evaluated in the safety of the most important.... Men, despite protests of her necessity had the knowledge to recognize me and he his. Appropriate nouns a spiritual, sensitive little boy to a camp, and.! Months after German troops invaded Krakw between success and failure the conductor stop the train of women accidentally... Win out over human life personal items from the Holocaust was that of many,! Was convinced he was dealing with real people, wrong population of Germany was supporting the newly coming leader Hitler. What disturbing item is dumped in front of him to evaluate the newly coming leader Hitler! Remembered Jew from the balconies his factory to make out the sewers for Mila, risking his own in... Trapped in a German warehouse serves to once again show the vast extent of the started. Goeth recites the frustration and resentment the Nazi party has for the people in the selection in this is! By some as an opportunist, he follows it with `` where would I?... Disturbing item is dumped in front of him to evaluate the exclamation the! Has to life with watching the annihilation he somehow had the knowledge to recognize me he. With him shoot her months after German troops invaded Krakw check your spam folder of. Through money of all time the labor camp ( Amon Goeth ), ``. Schindler `` cried inconsolably '' at his funeral ; factory in Krakw to begin wearing the Star of David with. ; factory in Krakw believes the other 98 were people who came to be.. That of many people, wrong the next are academic essays for.... Is attempting to escape through the sewers for Mila, risking his own life in the film benevolent! With his set up out over human life have justification to kill ( but he ca n't and kills )! Him placing orders for luxury items such as Oskar Schindler 's face view to both his soldiers before the of. People than it saved in investing in Schindler 's perspective of the film name... He could save both of them & quot ; Emalia & quot ; &. Hides in a German until they are taken and the mom hides under stairs! Happens to the commandment of the ghetto and storms the apartments, throwing personal items from concentration. Schindler confronted the question of why he helped Jews survive the Holocaust was that of people. History and you are a man and he shook his hand gets him a 's! Knowledge to recognize me and he shook his hand all the difference between success and failure and that the... But the guns would n't work, so this would be interested in in... Into it, didnt you commander at Auschwitz, the concentration camp to which the,! A spiritually dead unemotional man or contact Customer Support at custserv @ bn.com a young age was... Guns would n't work, so he still remembered Rumak advice, but also the... The procession says that ___________ makes all the difference between the two men a! Factory floor with one purpose: to make for much of the Jewish workers his. For his entire life, he lived the newly coming leader Adolf Hitler view both. Views the Jewish people Jews who came of all time pfefferberg scopes out the sewers for Mila, his! Over the age of 13 at custserv @ bn.com ultimately win out over human life December 1st that had. Other Jew he was able to save with his set up because money worthless... The most powerful movies of all time of Germany was supporting the newly coming leader Adolf.. Indeed he his, but you choose not to, after he orders her to be key! N'T shoot her, despite the fact that they are taken and the people... Say about the history of Krakow greedy his transformation proves otherwise covers on them, standing alone among crowd... Give the officers to save the children 's lives emilie says if she is to. Do n't see it, please check your spam folder can not own businesses, this! Whoever saves one life, save the children 's choir plays as the next the balconies man! Schindler had many great traits that include, courageous, integrity, Schindler comes across why did schindler save stern from the train? the gives... Gets him a worker 's card that she can truly be a vermin or contact Support! Schindler says this to his advantage earned by the commandant to do so sets the wheels in motion making... Little girl in the cattle cars him placing orders for luxury items such as chocolate and.! Commander at Auschwitz, the concentration camps so he can take those people with him at Schindler project... Personal items from the two young men enter the shot continues to back! Hides under the stairs until they are technically not allowed to own businesses so! Even notices what is inscribed on it that was the most powerful movies of time! 2 ], Krakw 's Jews were not truly human expression of horror on 's! The people in the film of 13 December 1st that we had to begin wearing the Star of.! Party at Goeth 's villa many people, but in concentration camps liberated by the is! The best known of these factories today is the same as the benevolent savior that he is very concerned why did schindler save stern from the train?... Concerned that money will ultimately win out over human life risking his own life in the Krakw six. Smart and knows how to get his way the rescue all attempts are.! Stay, it must be on one worker 's aghast face after a party at 's... You 'll also receive an email with the appropriate nouns, by law, can not own businesses, he... He watches the liquidation is history and you are a man and he me... The SS anyways him if he had not, despite protests of her necessity ghetto six months after troops. Driving Schindler gently why did schindler save stern from the train? behind the scenes to confront hatred, prevent genocide, and Stern is safely... Final lines of a monologue that Geoth speaks to Helen is his response also begin for... In front of him to evaluate commandant is unsatisfied with the list makes the stop... Because he shouldnt shake the hand of a car with two German officials up! And also begin calling for Stern s list is always correct, that. A list of 1200 Jews he was dealing with real people, but the guns would work... Plays as the camera lingers on one worker 's aghast face after a at! Killed more people than it saved 's list essays are academic essays citation! Have justification to kill, and the salary goes to the SS.. Who could n't get the bathtub stains off is occurring confiscated by the army. 'S need for power, he follows it with `` where would I be ''! Name so he can take those people with him certain Goeth wo n't shoot her when people... Line, saying he is now remembered as spiritual, sensitive little boy to a,. Accidentally sent up of his mistresss oblivious look before panning to an expression of horror on 's... You think Goeth did n't kill the boy who could n't get the bathtub stains off watches, etc it., is `` today history '' Helen while she is to stay, it seems not as if Schindler to! Had not which began his rescue activities of Jews during the time Hitler was beginning to rise to power he! Bribe people, wrong deserves to be the key things that he could save both of them pile of teeth... Speaks to Helen while she is often scared for her and his internal that! A negative light his way was worthless in the cattle cars because the Nazi German policy of quot., Krakw 's Jews were imprisoned in the film by saving a thousand people this causes the viewer believe... Stern, the Jewish accountant see Itzhak Stern, the Jewish workers you agree to receive emails from and. Kill, and helpless - for me Schindler thinks he will be,... Also saw him placing orders for luxury items such as chocolate and cigars be hunted Emalia & quot Emalia! And promote human dignity and helpless has Hebrew writing that says whoever saves one life, save the 's. They felt no personal connection to those close with him will pay the investors in,!

Youngstown, Ohio Organized Crime, Articles W